PHILADELPHIA, PA – Villanova University’s men’s basketball program, long the gold standard of success and integrity, now stands at a critical juncture. Once the envy of collegiate hoops, the Wildcats under Jay Wright evolved from an admired East Coast program to a permanent resident among the sport’s “blue bloods.” In his two decades as head coach, Wright led Villanova to six Big East titles, four Final Fours, and a pair of national championships, solidifying the Wildcats’ place alongside the likes of Duke, Kentucky, North Carolina and Kansas.

But Jay Wright’s abrupt departure in 2022 created a seismic shift on the Main Line. Wright had led an undermanned Villanova squad to the Final Four in his final season, only to vanish stage left, much to the surprise and disappointment of the Wildcat faithful. In a swift succession plan, Villanova’s leadership tapped former assistant Kyle Neptune to inherit the program — a coach respected for his Villanova pedigree but still untested at the program’s elite level. There was no search firm involvement, no long drawn out series of interviews with high profile national candidates. The president, the athletic director and, of course, Wright quickly anointed Kyle Neptune as heir to the Villanova throne.

In a matter of days, the Villanova brass handed Neptune the keys to the Lexus.

The move, while somewhat surprising, made sense on many levels. Neptune was no stranger to the Main Line. He spent eight years as an assistant on Wright’s staff with the Wildcats — he was on the sideline when Kris Jenkins knocked in his NCAA championship-winning 3-pointer in 2016. He left Philadelphia for the Bronx in March 2021 after being hired to coach Fordham. 

Neptune, took over as Fordham’s coach after the Rams finished an abysmal 2-12 in the pandemic-shortened 2020-21 season. In his lone season at Rose Hill Gymnasium, Neptune impressed, leading Fordham to a 16-16 record. This represented a 14-win improvement between the 2020-21 and 2021-22 seasons and the biggest single-season jump in program history.

After just one season in the Bronx, leading a perennially mediocre Fordham program, Wright tossed the keys to his protege. While he hasn’t “crashed the car,” alums and fans are definitely tired of Neptune driving over the rumble strips. This noise is both unfamiliar and undesirable to Main Line hoopheads. One can only assume that the sound inside the vehicle is just as intolerable. Nonetheless, it serves as a warning to a Neptune and his staff that they have been veering off the roadway.

This stakes could not higher for Neptune. He succeeded Wright on the heels of a Final Four appearance and is just 35-33 over the past two seasons. The Villanova program has dropped from perennial national championship contender to one that has been knocked out of the NIT in the first round the last two seasons. Villanova Athletic director Mark Jackson gave Neptune a strong vote of confidence at the end of last season and subsequently left for Northwestern and the Big 10. At some point during the basketball season, Neptune will get a new boss who will surely notice the fully loaded S-Class Mercedes Benz parked outside Harry A. Gampel Pavilion in Storrs, Connecticut.

A Proving Ground for Neptune

For Neptune, this season is more than just a chance to return to the NCAA tournament after a two-year absence. It’s an opportunity to affirm that Villanova’s reputation as a national powerhouse isn’t just a Jay Wright-era artifact. This is no simple task: He inherits both the pressure of a devoted fan base and the expectation to maintain a “Villanova brand” known for discipline, ball movement, and defensive intensity. Yet, for a program accustomed to national title contention, Neptune’s middling 35-33 record over two seasons is hardly a confidence booster. So… Exactly how will the staff return the Wildcats to prominence?

Philly Area Ballers on the Main Line

Neptune has leaned heavily on players from the Philadelphia region to bring Villanova back to prominence. Leading the charge is graduate student Eric Dixon. This Wildcat squad is Dixon’s team. Hailing from Abington, Dixon is extremely strong for a player at the college level and has often just powered to the basket during his illustrious college career. While he is undersized for the center position, Dixon uses his body very well, has great hands and good post footwork. He able to hold position on the blocks and back down his defender. On most nights, Dixon will be a serious mismatch for defenses in the low post. He posses a soft shooting touch around the basket uses a number of spins and drop steps to score However, it should be noted that he has expanded his offensive repertoire. Despite playing center, he was also tied for second on the team in three-point range attempts, knocking down just under 35% of his nearly five tries per game.  He runs the floor well for someone his size. Dixons plays good positional defense due to his above average lateral quickness and wide body. The Wildcats need Dixon to play at an All-American level if they are going to make the NCAA tournament after a two year hiatus.

Alongside Dixon is Jordan Longino, a Germantown Academy product who has shown glimpses of promise, albeit interrupted by injury. Averaging nearly 22 minutes per game last season, Longino’s shot and intensity on both ends of the floor could make him a consistent contributor — if he can stay healthy. The third key local returnee is Nnanna Njoku, whose power forward play and physical presence offer crucial support, though he, too, will need to avoid injuries to fully contribute.

New Faces, High Hopes

Surrounding the local returnees will be some key additions from the transfer portal. Manning the point guard position for Neptune will be Jhamir Brickus. A Coatesville High School legend,  Brickus is using his COVID bonus season of eligibility, after transferring from La Salle. Brickus played four seasons with the Explorers, and he had an outstanding campaign as a senior. He averaged 13.9 points, 3.5 rebounds, 4.8 assists, and just over a steal per game while hitting 40% of his threes. Brickus is a rock-solid choice to run the Villanova offense. He displays great court vision and makes his teammates better. He is an experienced, savvy, clutch vet who has seen it all. Brickus drives the lane like an NFL fullback, and either finishes strongly or finds the open man. Although relatively short in stature, he plays much bigger than his size on offense. He has been known to effectively post up bigger guards and forwards. Neptune has given him a chance to put his skills on full display before a national audience in Big East competition. 

A Philadelphia Public League legend will play on the wing for Neptune. Wooga Poplar, hailing from North Philly, is blessed with truly elite level explosiveness. Poplar was was one of the most intriguing prospects in college basketball last season and considered making the leap to the NBA this past off season. When he is healthy, Poplar displays electric speed and quickness, and is certainly one of the best leapers in college basketball. At MCS High School and subsequently the University of Miami, Poplar played an exciting and fairly flashy style. He is a highlight reel dunker in the transition game.  He has a sweet looking jump shot, and his range extends past the NBA 3-point line.  Poplar is able to hit shots off of screens or off the dribble, making him a guy who must be accounted for no matter what on the perimeter. He has more than adequate ball-handling ability  and will be a tough cover due to his athleticism and shooting skills. He has proven that he can slash when crowded or stop and pop if the defender gives him space. Poplar gets great elevation and has a high release giving him a great ability to get shots off. He has the ability to put up points in bunches.  A late blooming prospect, who wasn’t a highly touted recruit until late in his high school career, Poplar could really just be scratching the surface of his true ability.

They have added Enoch Boakye to play the center position while Dixon moves to power forward full-time. Boakye is an athletic forward with superior shot blocking and rebounding tools. He brings an evolving offensive game that includes the ability to finish lobs near the rim. last season with Fresno State. He gave the Bulldogs just short of 8 points and 8 rebounds a game. He brings much needed length and explosiveness to the Wildcat front court. 

Neptune did not go far for his final portal acquisition. He successfully recruited Tyler Perkins (6’4”, 205 lb, Lorton, Virginia), who was one of the best player in the Ivy League as a freshman at Penn last season. For the season, he averaged 13.7 points and 5.3 rebounds per game and hit nearly 35% of his three-pointers.  But, maybe… Just maybe, he’s at Villanova because he for dropped 22 points, six rebounds, and a block on the Wildcats in a 76-72 Quakers victory at The Palestra last season.

The Wildcats have also brought in in four freshmen, including two top 100 prospects. Matthew Hodge (6’8”, 200 lb, Belmar, New Jersey) is #70 in the 247 Sports Composite, while Josiah Moseley (6’6”, 185 lb, Round Rock, Texas) ranked #82. They also add redshirt freshman Kris Parker (6’9”, 195 lb, Tallahassee, Florida) on a transfer from Alabama where he did not play after ranking #99 in the 2023 247 Composite and Jordann Dumont, a versatile and athletic 6’8″ forward.

Neptune’s recruitment has been solid, but the question remains whether he and his staff can coach this talented roster to the program’s accustomed heights. Simply stated, can this staff coach these players to a level that results in deep runs in the NCAA tournament?

A Season on the Brink

The Wildcats’ early season schedule — including tests against St. Joseph’s, Virginia, and Maryland — offers Neptune a chance to prove that his Wildcats can hang with the best. But for the alumni and fans accustomed to the stability and success of Wright’s reign, patience may be wearing thin. The next few months will reveal if Neptune is indeed steering Villanova back on course or if, in the eyes of the Villanova faithful, the Wildcats’ time as a college basketball “blue blood” is starting to fade. 

We are about to find out Neptune can avoid the rumble strips early this year.